Skip to Content

Is Blood Type Personality Theory Scientific? - The Lie About Type A Being Timid

image

"You're Type A, so you're timid?" "Type B is self-centered." "Type O has leadership." The blood type personality theory, uniquely prevalent in Korea and Japan. Despite having absolutely no scientific basis, it feels like it's true. This is a perfect example of the Barnum Effect.

Related article: What is the Barnum Effect?

History of Blood Type Personality Theory​

Birth Background​

1927 Japan

  • Developer: Takeji Furukawa (teacher, not a psychology professional)
  • Purpose: Classify army soldier personalities
  • Basis: None (just belief)

Spread

  • Resurgence in Japan in 1970s
  • Introduced to Korea in 1990s
  • Spread through TV, magazines
  • Currently: Unique belief in Korea/Japan

Reality in Korea​

Blood Type in Daily Life

  • First meeting: "What's your blood type?"
  • Dating: "Type A and Type B don't match"
  • Workplace: "Type O must have leadership"
  • Friends: "So typical of a Type B"

Problems

  • Believed as science
  • Tool for judging people
  • Justifying discrimination and prejudice

Scientific Facts​

What is Blood Type?​

Medical Definition

  • Difference in red blood cell surface antigens
  • A antigen, B antigen, AB antigen, O (none)
  • Important for transfusions
  • Unrelated to personality

Connection to Brain?

  • Blood type = Red blood cell surface
  • Brain = Nerve cells
  • No connection
  • Mechanism unknown

Scientific Research Results​

Study 1: Japan (1980)

  • Participants: 1,000
  • Personality test by blood type
  • Result: Zero correlation

Study 2: Korea (2005)

  • Participants: 2,700
  • Compared blood type with Big Five personality
  • Result: No statistically significant difference

Study 3: Meta-analysis (2014)

  • Combined research from 10 countries (10,000+ participants)
  • Conclusion: No correlation between blood type and personality

Scientific Consensus

  • "Complete pseudoscience"
  • "Zero evidence"
  • "Superstition"

Why Does It Feel True?​

1. Barnum Effect​

Type A Description

"Meticulous and careful.
Tends towards perfectionism.
Considerate of others.
Sometimes considered timid."

Problems

  • Applies to everyone
  • Vague ("sometimes")
  • Dual description ("meticulous but timid")
  • → Classic Barnum Effect

Experiment

  • Show Type A description to Type B
  • "That's totally me!" reaction
  • Only label differs, content similar

2. Confirmation Bias​

Type A Person

  • Acts cautiously → "Typical Type A!"
  • Acts boldly → "Exception" (ignored)

Type B Person

  • Self-centered behavior → "So Type B!"
  • Considerate behavior → "Unusual for Type B" (dismissed)

Result

  • Remember only matching instances
  • Ignore contradictions
  • Illusion of "It really matches!"

3. Self-Fulfilling Prophecy​

"I'm Type B, so I'm free-spirited"

  • Belief → Influences behavior
  • Actually behaves more freely
  • Surroundings confirm "Typical Type B"
  • → Reinforces belief

Vicious Cycle

Belief → Behavior Change → Social Confirmation → Reinforced Belief

4. Group Think​

Social Learning

  • Exposed from childhood
  • Repeatedly hear "Type A is timid"
  • Unconsciously accept
  • Believe without doubt

Group Pressure

  • "Don't you believe in blood types?" → Treated as strange
  • Many believe → Doubt diminishes
  • Critical thinking suppressed

"Personality" Analysis of 4 Blood Types​

Type A (34% in Korea)​

Stereotypes

  • Meticulous, careful, timid, perfectionist, considerate

Barnum Effect Analysis

  • "Meticulous" = Everyone sometimes meticulous
  • "Timid" = Everyone sometimes timid
  • "Perfectionist" = Everyone pursues perfection in important matters

Type B (27% in Korea)​

Stereotypes

  • Self-centered, free-spirited, creative, moody

Barnum Effect Analysis

  • "Self-centered" = Everyone has personal needs
  • "Free-spirited" = Everyone dislikes constraints
  • "Creative" = Ambiguous expression

Type O (28% in Korea)​

Stereotypes

  • Leadership, sociable, optimistic, bold

Barnum Effect Analysis

  • "Leadership" = Everyone in certain situations
  • "Sociable" = Everyone with comfortable people
  • "Bold" = Everyone sometimes

Type AB (11% in Korea)​

Stereotypes

  • Dual-natured, unique, genius-like, multi-dimensional

Barnum Effect Analysis

  • "Dual-natured" = Everyone varies by situation
  • "Unique" = Everyone is unique
  • "Genius-like" = Pleasant-sounding (unproven)

Actual Damage Cases​

1. Dating Discrimination​

Case

  • "Won't date Type B men"
  • Breakup due to blood type
  • Forced relationships based on "compatibility"

Problems

  • Discrimination without scientific basis
  • Missing good people
  • Judging relationships by blood type

2. Hiring Discrimination​

Real Case (Japan)

  • "Type A only" job postings
  • Blood type questions in interviews
  • Placement decisions based on blood type

Legal Issues

  • Discriminatory practices
  • No scientific basis
  • Difficult to prosecute

3. School Bullying​

Cases

  • Labeling "Type B is selfish"
  • Ostracism based on blood type
  • Mocking "Type AB is weird"

Impact

  • Decreased self-esteem
  • Identity confusion
  • Self-doubt: "Am I really like that?"

4. Self-Limitation​

"I'm Type A, so I can't be a leader"

  • Not trying despite capability
  • Blood type as an excuse
  • Self-blocking growth opportunities

In Other Countries​

Western Countries​

Reaction

  • "Personality by blood type? Hilarious"
  • Scientific thinking prevails
  • Few believe in astrology

Differences

  • Individualistic culture
  • Strengthened scientific education
  • Critical thinking training

Japan​

Current Status

  • Similar prevalence as Korea
  • Common TV program topic
  • Increasing criticism recently

Changes

  • "Blood Type Harassment" recognized social issue since late 2000s
  • Spreading discrimination awareness
  • Growing critical perspective

Korea's Uniqueness​

Why Specifically Korea/Japan?

  • Collectivist culture → Preference for classification
  • Need for conversation topics
  • Lack of scientific thinking education
  • Uncritical media spread

Healthy Attitude​

DO ✅​

1. Just for Fun

  • Light conversation: "Oh, you're Type A~"
  • Icebreaking tool
  • Don't take seriously

2. Distinguish Science vs Superstition

  • Blood type = Medicine (transfusion)
  • Personality = Psychology (Big Five)
  • Completely unrelated

3. Respect Individual Differences

  • Even same blood type varies
  • Environment, education, experience more important
  • Don't judge people by labels

DON'T ❌​

1. Believe as Science

  • "Blood type is scientific" (Incorrect)
  • Zero evidence

2. Use as Judgment Tool

  • "Type B must be selfish" (Discrimination)
  • "Type A and Type B don't match" (Prejudice)

3. Use for Important Decisions

  • Dating, hiring, relationships
  • Never decide based on blood type

4. Impose on Children

  • "You're Type A, so you must be cautious"
  • Limits self
  • Hinders growth

Learn More​

Conclusion​

Blood type personality theory is a superstition, not science. It feels true because of the Barnum Effect.

Scientific Facts

  1. Zero Correlation - Proven by dozens of studies
  2. No Mechanism - Red blood cells unrelated to brain
  3. Developed by Non-Professional - 1927 Japanese teacher
  4. Believed Only in Korea/Japan - Not recognized globally

Why It Seems True?

  1. Barnum Effect - Descriptions apply to everyone
  2. Confirmation Bias - Remember only matching instances
  3. Self-Fulfilling Prophecy - Behave as believed
  4. Group Think - Believe because everyone else does

Actual Damages

  • Dating discrimination ("Won't date Type B")
  • Hiring discrimination (blood type restrictions)
  • Bullying (blood type stigma)
  • Self-limitation ("Can't do it, I'm Type A")

Healthy Attitude

  • ✅ OK for fun
  • ✅ OK as conversation topic
  • ❌ NOT scientific
  • ❌ NOT for judging people
  • ❌ NOT for important decisions

Remember

  • Blood type important for transfusions (medicine)
  • Personality shaped by experience, environment, choices (psychology)
  • Completely unrelated

Alternative

  • Want to know real personality? → Take Big Five test
  • Scientific basis
  • Can actually predict behavior

"It's not because you're Type A, it's because you're you."

Your blood type doesn't define you. Your choices and actions define you! 🩸❌